Thursday, 8 March 2012

Is all work experience equal?


Recently there has been lots of coverage of the government’s controversial efforts to give unemployed people unpaid work experience placements with private sector firms and the associated threat of loss of benefits if they fail to take part. 

The issue first came to my attention the voluntary and community sector press with the tale of Cait Reilly.  Cait was volunteering with a local museum as she wanted to find paid employment in that sector.  However she was told by her local Job Centre Plus to take part in a four week full time programme, including two weeks unpaid work at discount retailer Poundland, or face losing her benefits.  Responding to the story in Third Sector online, A Department for work and Pensions (DWP) spokesperson said:

“Working in retail is perfectly good experience for a career in a museum. There are very similar transferable skills involved.  It is simply absurd to suggest that we should not be providing this support and effectively leaving people at home doing nothing."

The story then got picked up by The Guardian newspaper as private sector firms and then charities started to pull out of such work experience schemes in the face of mounting opposition. In the face of this opposition the government recently changed its policy and removed the threat of benefit withdrawal from those refusing to take part in or dropping out of such programmes.

From a volunteering perspective there have, to my mind, been two issues with the government’s schemes. 

The first is the benefit sanction that people were threatened with.  Forcing people to volunteer or lose benefits is not ethical, regardless of which sector they are forced to work in.  Furthermore such practice breaches many agreements between government and the volunteering movement.  This sanction has now been removed so the issue is less of a concern.

However, throughout the ongoing saga, DWP, ministers and MPs have maintained that placing the unemployed into such work experience programmes is important if people are to find new work.  And that leads me to my second issue, the apparent presumption that only by taking part in these government endorsed schemes can people get good work experience. 

Whether it has been MPs, ministers or civil servants talking about the work experience schemes, all have been claiming that such programmes give people essential skills for the workplace. 

Look again at the DWP quote above relating to the Cait Reilly story.  According to the DWP spokesperson, unpaid work experience in retail is perfectly good experience for paid work in a museum.  I’m no expert on museum work but surely volunteering in a museum is even better experience for paid work in a museum?  Why on earth would you force someone doing volunteering that has such a clear link to their desired field of employment to stack shelves for two weeks?

What worries me about all these programmes is an apparent blind spot by government to the potential of volunteering to help people develop work skills.  Whether those skills are specific to a particular role or the so-called ‘softer’ skills (timekeeping, team work etc.) there is much evidence of volunteering helping to make people more employable as a basic search of the Institute for Volunteering Research evidence bank will demonstrate.

We may have won the battle over unfair sanctions if people don’t ‘volunteer’ but the bigger fight is, I fear, still ahead.  All of us working in the volunteering movement need to be ensuring that these work experience programmes don’t become the only valid way for people to gain employability skills.  We need to ensure that Job Centre Plus advisors, DWP officials, MPs and ministers are challenged to recognise the valuable contribution volunteering makes to building peoples’ skills and confidence for employment.

If we don’t then volunteering will become increasingly sidelined as a poor substitute for what are seen as more ‘valid’ forms of work experience.

Monday, 27 February 2012

Unpacking our online presence

Friend and colleague Jayne Cravens recently wrote a blog post entitled "Why I won't follow you on Twitter" which explained her reasons for engaging with others through a variety of social media.

This got me thinking that, almost a year on from the creation of Rob Jackson Consulting Ltd, it might be useful to explain the thinking behind the various social media and websites I am involved with in the hope that this will help you think about the best way for you to engage with me/the business (and  me/the business  with you).

Before I get started I will say that with only a few exceptions the media I'm talking about here are company accounts rather than my personal ones.  So the Facebook link is to the Rob Jackson Consulting Ltd page, not my personal Facebook page/timeline.  I keep the two separate so please don't put in personal follower requests if I don't actually know you.


Website
This is the front end to the world for the business.  It explains who we are, what we do and how we can help as well as quotes and recommendations about our work.  The homepage features links to our latest news, recent posts on Twitter and the latest from our blogs.  There isn't a lot of interaction here at the moment as that takes place via the social media covered below.

Blog
This blog is the main focus for my professional writing on a whole range of topics and issues.  Some of the content is in response to announcements, breaking news etc. and some of it is more think-piece oriented.  There is no set publication schedule and comments are always welcome, whether in agreement with what I say or to air different views.

You can follow the blog via log-in or email and/or take the RSS feed - all the boxes and links for these options are in the sidebar on the right of this page.

Third Sector blog
Once a month (usually around the 1st) I have an article published as Third Sector online's "voice of volunteering" blogger.  These posts are usually shorter than the main blog and look at a current issue or a reflect on the volunteering dimension to recent news in the voluntary sector.  As with the main blog, comments are very much encouraged.

Third Sector online is a subscription service so the blog may not be available to you unless you already subscribe to the online magazine.

Twitter
Twitter is perhaps the social network on which I am most active and where most people follow me/the business.  I use the RobJConsulting account for sharing news about my work, about issues in the sector and volunteering field, upcoming events, to promote work I am involved in and to engage in conversation with others, for example via the Thoughtful Thursday discussions run by Volunteer Centre Warrington.  Twitter is also where I gain a lot of my information about what's going on with issues and organisations I'm interested in.  To that end I have set up a number of lists which I follow, from news sources to Volunteer Centres, and anyone can subscribe to these.

Facebook
There is a company presence on Facebook although I did resist doing this for many months (I am similarly resisting Google+ as there are only so many hours in the day to keep on top of social media).  To date most of what is on the Facebook page is articles and stories that I also tweet, the exception being videos and pictures which I think work better posted to Facebook than Twitter.

Also, please note that I do not link the Twitter and Facebook accounts.  If you want to follow me/the business on both then please do so.

I am currently re-thinking how I use the Facebook page as I want to differentiate it from how I use Twitter, perhaps making more use of some of the more engaging features the site provides.  If you have any ideas about how you'd like us to use the Facebook page then please do let me know by leaving a comment below.

i-Volunteer
I have a presence on i-Volunteer under the username robjackson74.  I do occasionally post to the network, mainly commenting on articles other people's blogs, but I use it much more as a source of news and information.

Newsletter
Once a month (usually about the 16th) I publish the Rob Jackson Consulting Ltd newsletter.  This has recently undergone something of a facelift and re-launch for 2012 with a view to providing a wider range of content than just what I and the business have been up to.  So alongside some company news you'll find key news stories on volunteering related issues from the previous few weeks, information on useful resources and helpful tips and links.

The newsletter is powered by MailChimp, is totally free and unsubscribing is easy if you decide it isn't for you.

Latest news
The Rob Jackson Consulting Ltd website has the facility for its own dedicated RSS feed of latest news about the company.  A quick click through to the section will show a variety of stories from the past year, announcing events I was speaking at, conferences that were taking bookings, press releases for significant volunteering events etc..

LinkedIn - Rob
If you are interested in who I am and my professional background then you can find relevant information on the Rob Jackson Consulting Ltd website and on my LinkedIn profile.  The latter option gives access to a variety of recommendations about me and my work from throughout my career, my skills and experience and shows which other professional networking groups I am involved in on LinkedIn.

Please note that (for now at least) the company Twitter feed is linked to my LinkedIn account, meaning my tweets appear in my LinkedIn status.

If you want to connect with me via LinkedIn please bear in mind that I only really accept connections from people I know and am doing or have done business with.  I don't use it as a way to connect with people I don't really know so if I don't recognise who you are I probably won't accept your request to connect.

LinkedIn - Company
Aside from me personally the business has a presence on LinkedIn.  If you aren't familiar with company sites on LinkedIn then here is a quick run down of what you'll find on our page:

  • The landing page provides some brief summary information about the company, a link to my profile and the ability to sign up to follow the firm on LinkedIn.
  • The products and services page is where the real content is.  This provides a brief summary of the different services we offer alongside recommendations of our work from clients.  These clients' images can then be clicked on, giving you access to their profiles and thus the ability to get in touch and ask them about our work.

I'm a big fan of businesses having a presence like this on LinkedIn as it gives customers the chance to sound us out before they even make first contact.  That's an additional incentive for us to consistently deliver great customer services and satisfaction because we never know who is going to contact a client for a recommendation of our work.

If a business doesn't have such a transparent approach to what they do, ask what they might be trying to hide.

YouTube
One of my aims this year is to do more video blogging.  The company YouTube site is where those vlogs will feature.  It is also where you can view videos that I think have relevance to the volunteerism field & voluntary sector and where you can access some of the videos of other YouTube users I follow professionally.

Flickr
There isn't much I do on Flickr other than use it as a space to share photos of events the business has been involved in and promote the work of the photographers who I come across at conferences etc..

Skype
I'm on Skype, again as robjackson74.  I use it for free phone and video communication with colleagues across the world as well as cheap conference calling.  If you add me as a contact please do say who you are and why you want to connect.

UKVPMs
I am involved in moderating the UKVPMs email group which I set up in the late 1990's.  UKVPMs was the first online networking forum for UK based volunteer managers and now has over 1400 members.  It is free to join and more details can be found on the UKVPMs website.


I don't expect anyone to follow me on all of these sites (except perhaps for my mum - hi mum!) but to pick and choose the content and method of engagement that works best for you.  That's why there is a range of choice for you.

However you do decide to engage with me and/or the business, I look forward to meeting you online soon.

Tuesday, 14 February 2012

Volunteer rights – a long and winding road

As some of you may know I also write a monthly blog for Third Sector magazine online. Last June, in only my second blog post for them, I questioned whether the time was right for the sector to be addressing the issue of volunteer rights.  My posting was borne out of a frustration that the momentum built up by the Volunteer Rights Inquiry had seemed to stall somewhat.

Thankfully any drop in profile for the results of the Volunteer Rights Inquiry had only been a temporary blip and there are now more than 100 organisations who have pledged their support for the Inquiry’s 3R promise.


Yet still we read allegations of poor treatment of volunteers.  In November we had further reports into Jon Danzig’s dispute with the Pituitary Foundation and now we have the tale of Gillian Brocklehurst who, after being dismissed from Cylch ConwyDistrict Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB) after four years, had to bring a claim under the Data Protection Act to be allowed access to a report into her dismissal.


As with many other cases, this one centres around a CAB.  I don’t for one second think CAB consistently treat their volunteers poorly.  I do, however, think that their volunteers are more aware of their ‘rights’ and so feel more confident in bringing claims of unfair dismissal which is why we see so many

Citizens Advice are to be congratulated for conducting an investigation into the circumstances of Gillian’s dismissal.  Yet the latest developments in the story show that this investigation was flawed; that processes hadn't been followed; that communication was poor; and that evidence existed to suggest bullying and harassment had taken place.  

As was often seen during the work of the Volunteer Rights Inquiry, it appears the person who originally dismissed Gillian was a trustee – in this case Phil Ward, the chair of the CAB.  Whilst these situations can be blamed on poor volunteer management, the Volunteer Rights Inquiry found that sadly they are all too often due to poor governance, behaviour and management by senior staff and board members. 

So what can we learn from this and other similar situations?  


I think there are three things:

  • These are complex and emotive issues, made more so by a lack of clear legal status for volunteers and by the strong passions and emotions that often surround such cases.  To the volunteer, volunteering can be a deeply personal act and to be dismissed can be incredibly hurtful.  However justified an organisation may feel it is in taking the step to dismiss a volunteer, it must always be handled sensitively.
  •  In this day and age volunteers, just like anyone else, have very easy access to a variety of means to share their experiences far and wide.  Couple that with a media who much prefer negative stories to positive ones and the chances of your organisation being cast in a bad light greatly increase.  So if you must dismiss a volunteer, be completely open, fair and honest about why and always use it as an act of last resort.
  • We need to stop seeing such situations as problems for volunteer managers.  If senior managers and trustees are often a cause of these problems then they need to take their role in running a successful volunteer programme much more seriously.  We accept the need to develop their knowledge and skills around fundraising, why not volunteering too?


Whether these lessons are learnt or not, I fear quick solutions are not going to be forthcoming.  There is a long and winding road ahead of us with much distance still to be travelled, and many more to join the journey, before volunteers can be assured that they will not become the next Jon Danzig or Gillian Brocklehurst.