Tuesday, 10 April 2012

We need more Chief Executives who understand volunteer management


At a recent event in London, NCVO Chief Executive Sir Stuart Etherington remarked that head hunters working for voluntary and community sector organisations have shifted from looking for “skills such as presence, policy-making ability and influencing skills” to now just wanting to find “someone who knows how to make money”.

Some will no doubt be lauding this as an important step forward, with the sector recognising the importance of having fundraisers move into Chief Executive roles.  But I want to ask whether now is the right time for us to be looking for fundraising expertise at the top.

Don’t get me wrong, fundraising is important and more senior managers and trustees need to have a better grasp of fundraising in the sector.  However, in our age of austerity, when money is hard to come by and more people have less of it - and even less to give away - do we need more people at the top focused on drawing in such a scarce resource?  Can organisations really fundraise their way out of trouble?

Regular readers will be unsurprised to learn that, despite the importance of fundraising, I firmly believe that what we need more of at the top of our organisations is people raising skills.  We need Chief Executives, trustees, senior managers and others who can go beyond, as one person recent called them, ‘old world solutions to new world problems’ and think differently about how our organisations can grow and develop.

I’ve argued before that sector leaders seem worrying ignorant of – or at the very least blind to – the potential of volunteering.  This was reflected in the blog posts I wrote for Third Sector online about the recent State of The Sector research and, perhaps more worryingly, the implications of last year’s Leadership 20:20 report which looked at the future of voluntary and community sector leadership.  Even more recently Sir Stephen Bubb, Chief Executive of the Association of Chief Executives of Voluntary Organisations (ACEVO) questioned the whole premise of the government’s planned Giving Summit because of the 2012 Budget’s potential impact on major gift fundraising.

Volunteers today are increasingly different from those many have relied on over the years – the so called civic core of 8% of all volunteers who give nearly half the donated hours.  Today’s volunteers don’t thrill to such long term, time intensive commitments, at least not when they first start volunteering.  Instead they want more flexible ways to give time, engaging on their terms (not just ours), and bringing a wealth of talent, skills & experience to our organisations that in some cases far exceeds that to be found amongst the current paid workforce of the sector.  This is likely to become more and more commonplace as the baby boomers retire in greater numbers and seek opportunities to put their professional experience to work for the good of society.

What we need are senior leaders in the sector who understand these changes and can help steer organisations to adapt to them.  Leaders who can see how to harness the talents of Gen Y and baby boomer volunteers, re-distributing work according to who is best placed to achieve results not how much they get paid, and effectively stewarding all the resources at their disposal, not just those with a £ sign attached.

Maybe what the head hunters should looking for is more Chief Executives with experience of volunteer management.

But is that where we as volunteer managers aspire to be?

When I started in the field back in 1994 I had no idea that what I was doing was volunteer management.  I never saw this as a career and certainly never dreamed I’d do what I’ve done in the last 18 years.

So it is with many others.  Volunteer management has historically been a transitory field, with people coming into it as a route on to other roles in the sector or as an option that makes the transition back into the paid workforce after time away an easier one.

To my eyes it is only fairly recently that we have started to see more people coming into volunteer management as a career choice, something they want to spend much of their professional lives dedicated to.  Perhaps that’s why we hear more talk of qualifications and professional development now than we ever did before.

Of course it’s good news that we have so many bright and talented (and young!) people getting into the field, moving us forward and challenging those of us who’ve been around a while (you know who you are!) to keep up with the ever increasing pace of change. 

But what do we see as the pinnacle of that career path?

Is it heading a volunteer programme at a large national or international organisation?

Is it becoming a consultant in volunteer leadership and management, helping organisations get better at engaging volunteers?

Perhaps the pinnacle of a volunteer management career should be to move on from leading volunteer programmes and lead organisations instead, using our knowledge and experience to help shape volunteer involvement from the top job? 

Of course all these options (and more) are completely valid aspirations but do we need more volunteer managers looking at the last one – becoming a CEO? 

When so many Chief Executives seem to fail to ‘get’ volunteering, should we be aiming for more of us to take such jobs and influence from the top down not just the bottom up? 

Do our discussions around professional development focus on making people better volunteer managers but not potential Chief Executives? 

Should we – counter-intuitive as it may seem – be encouraging the best amongst us to stop being leaders of volunteer programmes and start being leaders of organisations?

What do you think?

Monday, 26 March 2012

Using the budget to encourage volunteering

The UK government debated its annual finance bill on 21st March (commonly referred to as Budget Day).  Amongst the initiatives and changes outlined by The Chancellor, George Osborne, was a cap on income tax reliefs.

In practice this would mean government would limit the amount of tax relief an individual can claim in any year to a quarter of their income or £50,000, whichever is higher, from April 2013.  The intention of the policy change is to stop the well-off dodging tax via making charitable donations.

The response of the voluntary sector has been swift and firm with six sector umbrella bodies immediately writing to The Chancellor expressing concern about the impact this change would have on the propensity of the wealthy to make major gifts to good causes.  According to Third Sector Online, the letter states that:

"There is a clear danger that this measure could have the unintended consequence of disincentivising the donation of large gifts to charity. Charities rely heavily on major philanthropy of this kind, and any reduction in giving could be devastating for many vulnerable people who rely on our services. The measure is also clearly at odds with the government’s commendable efforts to promote philanthropy, sending the wrong signal to major donors who have thus far been encouraged to give more."

Indeed some sector leaders are arguing that the Giving Summit planned for May 2012 is "in danger" as a result of this change in policy.

Put aside for a moment the question of whether the voluntary sector should be lobbying against a policy that limits tax breaks for the wealthy in order to help the public purse and thus support those who are less well off.

Put aside the uncomfortable feeling that the self-interest of those organisations who gain from the big gifts of the wealthy seems to be dictating a policy that is being pursued in the name of the whole sector, a sector where relatively few organisations gain from such gifts but many are working hard at the coal face to help fight the effects of inequality.

Put aside the fact that yet again the sector's leaders seem totally fixated on cold hard cash as the only resource with which the sector can do anything, to the extent that panic ensues when they risk losing some of it.

Instead, consider whether there could be an opportunity here.  Over on Volunteering England's Dialogue App I've made a suggestion for how the sector could be a bit creative with this financial policy change from the government.

My idea is that some of the income tax relief for the well-off are restored in return for time given. So instead of the relief being capped at a quarter of their annual income or £50,000, whichever is higher, if someone gave £10,000 of their time to a good cause this cap could be raised accordingly.

I'm the first to admit that I'm no tax expert and so there may well be issues with this suggestion that I am unaware of.  Equally, there would need to be agreement about the value accorded to someone's time, a system for recording and verifying the hours they volunteer and some way of ensuring their time is donated by them to genuine good causes.

But those problems don't seem insurmountable and consider the benefits.

Such a scheme could:


  • Help maintain major gifts be restoring higher level of relief for those most likely to give big gifts
  • Draw in additional human resource to work on social problems as these people give their time as volunteers
  • Help to change the mindset of the sector that cash isn't the only way to get things done
  • Help promote new models of 'skilled' pro-bono style volunteering as the people likely to be affected by the proposed changes to income tax relief are wealthy business people who may well have considerable professional expertise to share through their volunteering.

Surely it is worth some consideration?

UPDATE
Ami Bloomer at Give What You're Good At has flagged two of her blog posts that link quite nicely with my proposal.  The first outlines the arguments for and against tax relief for pro bono (volunteering) work and the other argues that skilled volunteering is a great way of engaging major donors and encouraging them to give.

Tuesday, 20 March 2012

The trouble with criminal record checks

It is the issue that simply won't go away.  Whenever volunteering gets mentioned it seems three little letters won't be far away.  They are there in media coverage and an ever present source of questions whenever I run workshops, training sessions and sit on conference panel discussions.

I give you CRB, or criminal record checks.  That's what they get called in England although they have different names in different parts of the UK and indeed other countries around the world.

Early on in my volunteer management career I worked for Barnardo's, one of the oldest and biggest UK charities working with vulnerable children and young people.  At the time only a small number of organisations had access to criminal record checks so the vast majority of volunteer involving organisations - without access to police checks as we called them then - applied a number of screening techniques in order to manage the risk to their clients from involving 'unsuitable' volunteers.

Within the context of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exceptions Order 1975) these included:

Application forms - they paid close attention to the information prospective volunteer supplied, looking for inconsistencies, gaps in employment records etc..

References - considerable care was taken to secure at least two good quality references.  Usually this involved one professional reference and one personal reference, the evidence from programmes like Big Brothers and Sisters in the USA suggesting that personal referees were much more likely to reveal details of someone's past that might prevent them from volunteering then previous litigation-fearful employers.

Canadian screening expert Linda Graff often argues that references are a hugely under-used tool in screening and her book "Beyond Police Checks" is still an essential read in the field of volunteer screening and is highly recommended.

Interviews - ideally done by two people, interviews (whether you call them that or not) we an essential  screening tool.

Supervision - ongoing regular supervision to check on the volunteer, what they are doing, what they are struggling with, what support they need etc. and to address issues that arise, whether formally or informally.

Appraisals - whether annually or more frequent, formal check points in addition to ongoing supervision were important to review the volunteers' place and role within the organisation and to flag issues if they have arisen since the last meeting.

User and volunteer feedback - looking for the views and opinions of service users and other volunteers, both on the whole programme and on the work of other volunteers.  This was/is formally enshrined by some in whistle-blower policies.

Above all organisations - whether they had access to police checks or not - employed a suite of tools to screen people wanting to volunteer with vulnerable clients.  They didn't do one thing, they followed a screening process, an ongoing process that didn't stop when recruitment finished.  Critically they spent time considering all these tools in the round to look for clues as to somebody not being a suitable volunteer.

In training I often quote an example of the importance of screening being a process and one where the different elements inter-relate and so need checking against each other (names have been changed to protect the possibly guilty).

I was once cross checking the police check application and volunteer application forms of a potential volunteer at Barnardo's.  All looked good at first glance.  Upon closer inspection, however, I noticed that on one form the surname was Brown and on the other Browne.  The dates of birth were also out by a day.  We followed up with the person concerned and heard nothing more from them.  Now, they might have been totally innocent and never responded because they'd changed their minds about volunteering.  But, what if?  What if they had been deliberately trying to sneak through the system with misinformation, hoping nobody would spot it?  Without that close attention to detail cross-referencing the two forms we might never have spotted a potential risk to our clients.

So that's how things used to be.

Then, in 1997, the Police Act came into force.  Part five of the act provided the legislative basis for the Criminal Records Bureau to be formed and the introduction of CRB checks to a much wider range of organisations.  The CRB set out guidance and code of practice on checking volunteers that explained who could be checked and at what level.  These documents were seen as important both to ensure that checking was only done where appropriate and necessary and to set it within a proper context of the wider screening systems organisations should employ.

Yet despite this guidance, some organisations still seem to conduct checks on everyone who volunteers, not just those who should be checked because of their access to vulnerable people.  See this excellent blog from Jamie Ward-Smith on i-volunteer that sums up many people's experience with CRB checks.

Many organisations  appear to behave as if a clearance from the CRB is a guarantee that volunteers pose no risk to clients.  Many organisations seemingly fail to properly employ a wide range of screening techniques and seek to cross reference the information prospective volunteers supply in order to spot irregularities and possible causes for concern.

Instead we have a narrative around and a practice focus on volunteer screening that is fixated with CRB checks, almost always to the exclusion of any other screening method.  Don't get me wrong, CRB checks can be an important screening tool and we should have access to them, but their value is only realised if they are used as part of a comprehensive screening process, not if they are the screening process.

Yes there are organisations out there doing great work screening volunteers well and effectively safeguarding vulnerable people.  Sadly however, the overall picture of the last fifteen years appears to be one of more and more reliance on CRB checks.  Consequently I fear we've lost many of the skills and subtle understanding needed to properly safeguard vulnerable people as we've become more reliant on a single check that is out of date as soon as it is conducted.

In short, the trouble with CRB checks is that: we have become worryingly reliant upon them; we gain a false sense of safety by conducting them; and consequently we are less safe because of them.

What do you think?

Do you agree with me?

Have you got tips or stories to share on effective volunteer screening that goes beyond CRB?

Whilst the context of this post on CRB checks is very much my experiences in England I hope those of you from other countries will see your own parallels with the issues I raise.

Please use the comments facility below to share your own thoughts or experiences of criminal record checking, whether you agree with me or not.