Friday, 7 February 2014

Warning! The volunteers are coming

Earlier this week friend and colleague Lynn Blackadder shared with me the latest issue of National Museums Directors' Council newsletter. Within the newsletter there was a heading reading,"Volunteers may run libraries, parks and museums warns local government chief". Underneath it was the following text:

Writing for the Daily Telegraph the Chairman of the Local Government Association Sir Merrick Cockell warns that it will be impossible for local councils to keep paying for all the services they currently offer as cuts increase.  He writes “with half of local government’s savings still having to be found before April 2016, and more cuts promised thereafter, it will no longer be possible to keep slicing away at budgets without services suffering or, in some cases, disappearing completely.” 

“We now need to be asking whether people are prepared to take a direct role in providing other services like the running of local museums, sports classes, the upkeep of parks and green spaces and the management of allotment sites.” The Telegraph reports that the LGA estimates that local councils will have to find a further £10bn savings from their budgets, on top of the £10bn cuts already made. Telegraph (Sir Merrick’s article), Telegraph (commentary)

In the last few years, whilst the purse strings have been rapidly tightened following the global financial crash, the debate about volunteers making a greater contribution to the delivery public services has been focused almost exclusively on the risks of these volunteers going paid staff out of work. In public fora, leaders and managers of volunteers have remained largely silent on the issue except for occasional support for the position that volunteers shouldn't do the work that paid staff once did - as if the argument were that simple. In fact Lynn and I tried to address this complexity in a piece for The Guardian back in 2011.

Rarely has anyone spoken about the upside to volunteer involvement in public services. The more positive aspects of the (in many ways rightly) much maligned Big Society agenda that focused on local people having more of a say in how services are delivered & taking more ownership of those local services have seemingly been forgotten.

This leads me to think that if we'd had an intelligent, open and informed discussion about volunteer involvement in public services a few years ago we perhaps wouldn't have to resort to the interesting language you may not have noticed in the headline to the article quoted above  - "Volunteers may run libraries, parks and museums warns local government chief".

Why is this something to warn us about? Are volunteers such scary people that we should be in fear of them when visiting the local museum in future?  Or is it a warning that 'the volunteers are coming, be in fear for your jobs'? Or perhaps its a warning to the public, the old 'volunteer or lose it (the library, park, leisure centre etc.)' recruitment tactic.

Either way I can't help but feel we've got a situation of our own making here. With either total silence or well intentioned arguments against job substitution from the volunteer management community, we have perhaps missed a huge chance to speak up and educate. We have perhaps missed a golden opportunity to say how volunteers - either on their own or working alongside paid staff - need not be a threat but an opportunity to transform public services for the better.

The good news is that opportunity need not be entirely a missed one. We can still speak up and be heard. In our own organisations, in online forums, in comments to news articles, on social media, at conference and events, we can take a more positive line on how volunteers can add real value to public services.

Interestingly, the Association of Volunteer Managers (AVM) is developing a code of conduct for its members (and if you work with volunteers here in the UK you should be a member of AVM) which, if adopted, would require them to "advocate on behalf of volunteers at all times". In other words, we would be compelled to take a positive stance for volunteers in the delivery of public services as a matter of professional conduct.

So my question to you is whether you are ready to do this? Are you prepared to counter the warnings about volunteer involvement and champion the value they can add and good they can bring? Indeed, have you done this before and got tips to share? If not, what kind of information and support do you think you'd need to be confident in fighting the corner of the volunteer?

Please share your responses below.



If you'd like to read some of my blogs on job substitution (or, as I prefer, job displacement & replacement) please see  my previous posts on this issue and my column for Third Sector online too.  I've also stuck my head above the parapet and commented on stories about more volunteers working in libraries. 

Tuesday, 21 January 2014

Can the voluntary sector learn from the army?



Just a few days ago colleague Kirsty McDowell published and excellent posting on her blog, “Can the army learn from the voluntary sector”. Kirsty rightly argues that the challenges faced by the military to recruit more reservists (volunteers) to the army could have been reduced if they had taken time to learn from what works in volunteer recruitment.

Good customer service, speedy responses to enquiries, an online applications that works, well briefed frontline staff - we all know that these things make a big difference to effective volunteer recruitment and, where they aren’t present, can act as a significant barrier to prospective volunteers.

But can it work the other way? Can the voluntary sector learn from the army?

The answer is yes.

Consider for a moment that much volunteer recruitment is still focused on messages like “help, we need volunteers”, or “help, we urgently need volunteers”. All the good systems and processes in the world won’t be worth much if we can’t inspire people to consider giving us their time in the first place.

The army, on the other hand, may not have the best systems for handling new reservist recruits but they do have a compelling and inspiring way of marketing their roles. Let’s face it, they have to if they are going to convince people to sign up for something where they may well find themselves laying their lives on the line - just like this famous advert Ernest Shackleton used to recruit volunteers to his Antarctic expedition:
No “we desperately need your help” there, instead it challenges, it inspires and it makes it abundantly clear to many (including me) that they are not the ones to volunteer for that particular challenge!

Beyond the front end of the posters, radio, internet and TV adverts the Army uses to attract their kind of people, their recruitment website highlights some lessons many volunteer involving organisations could learn:

Training and development - the army is up front that its recruits have a wealth of opportunities available to them from apprenticeships & learning a trade to a multitude of specialist roles. Do our organisations explain how we can help our prospective volunteers to learn their role and develop during their time with us?


Roles tailored to the interested of the individual - army recruits have access to thousands of jobs, and hundreds of careers. Do we offer choice and flexibility to our prospective volunteers during their 'career' with us or do we lock people into the role we need and keep them there forever?


Information for families - the army are very clear about how they can provide welfare and support services to their troops, family care for their dependents and how they can helping people move on at the end of their army career. Do we explain what support we’ll give to the volunteer? Do we show that we can be flexible and adaptable to the other needs in their lives (family, friends, work etc.)? In particularly emotionally demanding roles, do we explain the welfare and support we’ll provide to volunteers? Do we ever offer them support to find new volunteer roles when they decide to leave?


Socialising and fun - the army explicitly promote events, activities and leisure to their recruits, showing that a career is more than just the job but the social side of what they offer? Are we explicit about this with potential volunteers? Do we involve them in social activities? Or are volunteers expected to just turn up, do their role and then disappear rather than becoming a part of the team?

So yes, the army can definitely learn from us. But we can also learn from them. I’ve only touched on a few areas here - I haven't even touched on leadership - so please do comment and let me know how else we might learn from the army (and other armed forces) when it comes to working with volunteers.

Tuesday, 10 December 2013

She's Electric

One of the things I love to do in my work and my writing is showcase examples of the volunteering people do. I'm a big believer that people can inspired to volunteer by seeing and hearing about example of people just like them who manage to fit volunteering in to their busy lives.


To that end, this posting is from guest blogger and friend Katriona Bailey. Kat shares her experiences of volunteering and I hope others will be inspired by it.

>>>>>>>>>


It is April 2011, I am sitting in my car looking at the building in front of me. I am debating whether to go in or whether to drive home......inside is a man called Graham Main - and he has had the idea to start up a community choir in my home town. I am curious but terrified. My curiosity gets the better of me and I make my way in....there are a total of around 12 people who have shown up to find out more.


Fast forward to July 2013 - Wickerman festival - headlined by Primal Scream - but also playing to a packed tent are Dumfries community choir - all 100 of us. We go down a storm. Hours later, as I bop around to Dexy's Midnight Runners, a man approaches me - "they're good" he says "...but you guys were better".


This would all be an achievement in itself but the choir is now only a small part of what Graham and his colleagues do. It turns out there was a hunger in the town for a creative outlet and Graham has built "Electric Theatre Arts" from nothing and I am proud to say that I am the company secretary, a voluntary role that I LOVE. As a mother of 2 who works full time, I was unsure about taking on this role - where would I find the time? But let me tell you - I do find the time - and I get so much more out than I put in.


My role is varied, sometimes I have lots of things to do, sometimes not so much. Being a board member allows me to pop in and out of the building, to interact with the users of the service and to see the difference it makes in peoples lives. I love being involved and even though I have lived here all my life, I have never felt a strong sense of community here until I got involved.


Electric theatre arts is a non profit community interest company. We run youth theatre groups for kids and young people from 5 - 25, music groups for pre school kids, we have adult Spanish classes, samba classes, you can come in and learn the piano, the drums, the guitar, we will rent you a rehearsal space for your band. And all of this is done at the lowest possible cost to make it accessible for all. We now have a full time employee who is going out into the poorest areas of the town and to outlying regional towns to try and set up creative opporunities for the young people there.


It is a pleasure to be involved. I would recommend anyone to take on such a role if an opportunity presents itself. it will pay you back tenfold.


You can find more information on the organisations mentioned in this blog at www.electrictheatreworkshop.com, www.Dumfriescommunitychoir.com,  www.Dumfriesyouththeatre.com.