In
my
Third Sector blog this month I have written wrote about changing people’s
perceptions of volunteering. I hope I
encourage those who read my post to celebrate all kinds of volunteering and, in
doing so, help show a side to volunteering that goes beyond the traditional
stereotypes of volunteers being long-serving older people so common in the
media.
Sadly, another common perception of volunteers is that they
are not trustworthy and cannot be relied upon.
I have lost count of the times I’ve heard people say that volunteers
cannot be given access to confidential information or entrusted with
‘important’ roles because they might not turn up to do them.
Volunteers are no more inherently untrustworthy or
unreliable than paid staff. Such
attitudes are often borne out of ignorance about volunteering and even fear
that volunteers may do a better job than paid staff.
So in some ways I was not surprised to read that volunteers
for the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic games were having strict rules
imposed on them by
LOCOG,
effectively banning the use of social media.
Initial responses from volunteer managers on
UKVPMs seemed to support
LOCOG, acknowledging that there were potential confidentiality and security
issues at stake and that a social media policy would be found in most places so
why not the Olympics. The criticism
seemed more focused at the way the policy was introduced not the fact that it
existed at all.
In my view this misses the point. LOCOG’s policy appears to be driven from a
view that volunteers will be tweeting and posting sensitive information at
every available opportunity. In other
words, that volunteers cannot be trusted and are inherently likely to screw
things up.
Why? What evidence do
they have for this? Surely volunteers
will be just as concerned about their safety and that of others as anyone
else? Why then assume they’ll be
snapping pictures of security sensitive things and posting them online?
As one contributor to the debate on UKVPMs put it:
“Instant communication
is the norm now and to try and restrict it is a sure fire way to anger people
and end up with the situation you were trying to avoid in the first place. That
is, I'm sure most people would have been tweeting about how much of a good time
they were having, whereas such a policy suggests they would expect people to do
otherwise. Doesn't say much for their opinion of the volunteers or their
respect for their goodwill.”
I wonder, do LOCOG have such rules in place for Olympic
staff and athletes or are they more trusted than volunteers? And where is the voice of the LOCOG volunteer
management team, standing up for the Games Makers rather than kowtowing to
this policy of their communications colleagues?
There are lots of other reasons why LOCOG’s rules are a daft
idea. Blogger
Paul
Adams outlines some of these from a social media perspective.
Just under 24 hours after the original story broke the BBC
also
reported
that the British Olympic Association wants London 2012 to be the ‘Twitter
Games’.
Perhaps LOCOG’s communications team (all paid staff I would
guess) should have been more reliable and professional about doing co-ordinating
their messages with their Olympic partners instead of assuming the worst about
the online behaviour of their volunteers?